Lee DeWyze's first song choice was Lynyrd Skynyrd’s “Simple Man,” a tune previously performed by season 5’s Bucky Covington but not with the conviction of Lee’s version. That’s because this guy from the Chicago suburbs is about as meat and potatoes as they come, and he makes no apologies for it -- It’s what’s brought him this far. And that’s exactly the sentiment that the song puts forth. A smart move for Lee in these final days.
Lee’s “Simple Man” inspires some serious swaying in the front, and way in the back, his vocal sounds strong and clear. Ending the song with a smile and props for the band, Lee nods in agreement when Randy declares that he’s in it to win it. Ellen’s comparison to a “little baby lamb” brightens the mood even more as does Kara’s comment that round 1 goes to Lee, but for Simon’s turn, Lee stands with clenched fist. Fortunately, it’s good news as the panel’s most important judge describes the choice as “absolutely on the money” and a performance that “crushed” the other two.